Ever since Pixar burst onto the scene with Toy Story, its first CGI-animated feature film in 1995, it has consistently produced high quality and well-grossing films. And while the studio paved the way for a renaissance in CGI animation and, in turn, unfortunately lessened the mass appeal of 2D animation, its films have been able to capture the magic usually found in Disney 2D animation films from the past.

Now, 17 years later, this weekend will see the release of Brave, Pixar’s 13th feature film. That has inspired 5 of us — film contributors Paolo and Steve, anime contributor Erin, manga contributor Melanie and myself — to rank every Pixar film until we collectively came up with the 5 best. And boy was it close.

Did your favorite Pixar film make the list? Hit the break to view Pop GO’s 5 best Pixar films!